Chocolate Fudge Pie is a delicious, rich and decadent homemade chocolate pie, made from scratch! The perfect solution when you need a quick and easy dessert – made in just a little over an hour! In the fall, this dessert is the best thanksgiving pie recipe.
A Simple Chocolate Pie Dessert Recipe
No, don’t get me wrong! I really love my son Marco’s birthday party, but some of the things can simply make me go crazy! Come to think of it, those are not birthday, but more “postbirthday” concerns. And here is what it’s about!
Since we want as many guests as possible at the party every year, we simply rent our favorite restaurant. Of course, counting on most of the guests coming, besides the birthday cake, I always make a ton of cakes, salty nibbles and little things like that. And always, some of the guests are not able to come. Doesn’t matter! But then, for days, we have to eat all the food that is left from the party! An even bigger problem is that the guests that could not make it to the party, still want to see Marco and give him a present, so they come days and days after his actul birthday. And so, the party sometimes lasts 10 days “after”.
And this year, the usual few days became two weeks. Last on the guest list was my dear cousin Dobby, who said he was coming 15 days after the party to pay a “birthday visit”. Well, OK, when we were able to survive everything until now, we will also survive this also. But this time, there was nothing from the party left in my kitchen. And my cousin Dobby who has „sweet tooth“, just like me, always looked forward to the visits because he knew something sweet was waiting on the table.
So, what delicious treat to prepare and not spend the whole day in the kitchen? I know that my cousin is a great chocoholic, just like me, but baking a cake was too complicated at that moment. And then I got the answer in two words!!! Chocolate pie! Decadent enough and not that complicated. That is it!
Rich Homemade Chocolate Fudge Pie
I have to admit that chocolate pie was not that often on the menu, so for that reason, I made a little internet reasearch. Most recipes I found were for the beautiful French Silk Chocolate Pie, but since I had already made this beautiful treat, my choice was the simple but decadent Chocolate Fudge Pie. And how was it in the end? Well, if you are looking for something really, really chocolaty, then this is the excellent choice for you! Beautiful taste of chocolate in combination with a thin pie crust – yummy 🙂
And the best witness of the things I’m telling you about is my good cousin Dobby, who was so delighted after a few tasty slices of Chocolate Fudge Pie that he took a few slices with him “for the road” 🙂 .
PrintChocolate Fudge Pie
- Prep Time: 25 minutes
- Cook Time: 50 minutes
- Total Time: 1 hour 15 minutes
- Yield: serves 8-10 1x
- Category: Dessert
- Method: Oven
- Cuisine: American
Description
Chocolate Fudge Pie is a delicious, rich and decadent homemade chocolate pie, made from scratch! The perfect solution when you need a quick and easy dessert – made in just a little over an hour! In the fall, this dessert is the best thanksgiving pie recipe.
Ingredients
For the crust:
- 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon sugar
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter (cold and cut into half inch cubes)
- 2–4 tablespoons cold water
For the filling:
- 1 cup half and half
- 1/4 cup unsalted butter
- 8 ounces bittersweet chocolate-chopped
- 1 1/2 cups sugar
- 3/4 cup cocoa powder
- 1/4 cup all-purpose flour
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 2 eggs
- 3 egg yolks
Instructions
To make the crust:
- In a large bowl whisk together flour, sugar and salt.
- Add butter and mix with a fork until it starts to look like a coarse meal.
- Add 1 tablespoon of water at the time and continue mixing until a dough forms.
- Wrap the dough with the plastic wrap and refrigerate for 2 hours.
- Lightly greased 9-inch pie plate and preheat oven to 350 F.
- Take the dough from refrigerator and roll out on a lightly floured work surface into a circle about 1/8 inch thick.
- Transfer the dough to a pie plate and trim excess of a dough from edges.
To make the filling:
- In a bowl whisk together sugar, cocoa powder, flour, and salt.
- Combine in a sauce pan half and half, butter, and chocolate and stir over a medium-low heat until it become smooth.( Let it cool a few minutes before you add it over dry ingredients and eggs)
- Add eggs, egg yolks and chocolate mixture into dry ingredients and stir until well-combined
- Transfer filling to pie crust in pan.
- Bake 45 to 50 minutes (until the center is set and the edges start to crack)
- Cool 10-15 minutes before serving.
100 comments
What is half and half ?
Hi Anita, half and half is diary product of equal parts light cream and milk, and has 10-12% milk fat. You can substitute 4-1/2 teaspoons melted butter plus enough whole milk to equal 1 cup.
Hi Vera. I loved it. Everyone at home fell in love with it as well and asked for the recipe. I just loved the texture. One thing that I’d change, though, is that I’d bake the crust before hand, then add the filling. The crust beneath the filling ended up soft and kinda raw, but hey, I might’ve done something wrong. Thanks you so much for sharing this beauty! Greetings from Brazil.
Is the pie crust/pan for a deep dish ? or regular sized ? thanks
I used reg pre-made crust and have enough filling for another pie left over. I’m also frosting it with German chocolate frsting.
Is half and half the same as buttermilk?
No, but you can substitute 1 cup half and half with 4-1/2 teaspoons melted butter plus enough whole milk to equal 1 cup.
Oh my goodness, this looks amazing! I pinned it to the party board! 🙂
Thanks Marty 🙂
I didn’t see what temperature to put the oven on?
Hi Molly, preheat the oven at 350F
Happy baking 🙂
I have made this pie several times. In fact, I’m making it now! I’m waiting for the chocolate mixture to cool before folding it all together and popping it in the oven. I follow the recipe exactly, and it always turns out fabulous. It’s my go to chocolate fix. I can’t wait!
I want to make this now but it’s raining and I don’t want to go to the store. I have 2%, sweetened condensed and evaporated and dry milk but no whole milk……….
Hey this look nice! I just have one doubt, do you bake the crust and the filling together or first you have to bake for a while the crust and then add the filling? I don’t know if I geet it well and I don’t want either tu burn the crust or make the whole pie raw
Thank you!
Hi Yora,bake the crust and the filling together, you don’t have to bake the crust before you add the filling.
Looks so delicious; do leftovers need to be refrigerated? Thanks!
Hi Virginia, keep the leftovers it in the fridge.
Made this pie for a friends birthday, big hit, everyone wants the recipe, think I’ll keep it to myself though,. Thanks for making me the chocolate pie queen at work.
Hi Tamara I’m glad that you like my recipe 🙂
Hello I made this last night and it came out beautiful! it is the perfect texture and didn’t under/over cook at all. my only concern is that its very bitter. I just checked my cocoa and it says unsweetened. I see it doesn’t specify on this recipe. did you use sweetened cocoa?? I may try it with a sweeter chocolate. I love how easy the crust was!
Any update here. I’d like to make tomorrow. Do you think semi sweet morsels would make a difference?
Hi Christie, I think it will work, too.
I used 1/2 bittersweet, 1/2 semisweet and unsweetened cocoa. It is still really dark. If I make it again I will try all semisweet to lighten it up.
What is ‘half and half’?
Hi Liz, it’s dairy product-mixture of one part milk and one part cream. You can find many homemade substitute recipe all over the web.
Can I use heavy cream?
I made this, substituted evaporated milk and semi sweet morsels, cut down on the sugar. Wasn’t very good.
You used the wrong milk, chocolate, and sugar and call it a bad recipe? That’s user error, not the recipe. Please keep that in mind when reviewing a recipe. I made it today and thought it was delicious! It’s more of a darkish chocolate but so good. I would serve it up with some freshly whipped cream.
I made exactly as written and I thought it was too dry. I’ll try adding more half and half next time
Make you a chocolate cream cheese and it will be creamy. This is as stated, chocolate fudge pie.
I don’t get substituting everything in the pie and then saying it wasn’t very good either. Either get the right ingredients or simply make a different pie.
cost is a huge reason i substitute, a huge reason especially today
Hi this might be a weird question but will tho crust also work out for a pumpkin pie crust? I currently don’t have any baking powder or baking soda in my house and I was jut wondering if I could use the recipe for this simple crust for pumpkin pie or if you have any suggestions on a easy pie crust that doesn’t involve a lot of ingredients
Hi Adry, I think you could use it for pumpkin pie, too.
[…] Chocolate Fudge Pie from OMG Chocolate Desserts […]
[…] Via omgchocolatedesserts.com […]
I don’t have half and half, but have heavy whipping cream and whole milk. What do you think would work better – butter and whole milk substitute or heavy whipping cream?
Also, I’m making this for my husband’s bday. Should I wait and bake it just before we eat it, or is it ok to bake ahead of time and warm before serving?
He loves dark chocolate. Can’t wait to serve this tonight. Thank you!
Hi Beverly, you can use butter and whole milk substitute.You can bake it ahead of time,I like it even more when it’s cooled completely,but it is a matter of taste.
Happy bday to your husband 😉
Thank you for your quick reply! Off to borrow some eggs now! 🙂 Baking ahead is a huge help with 3 basketball games before we can properly celebrate! Looking forward to making this a staple!
can i use evaporated milk insted of whole milk?
You can use evaporated milk instead of half and half.
My family doesn’t care for bittersweet chocolate. will Milk or a lower % of Cocoa (in the form of a chocolate bar) work? like Milk chocolate for instance??
Hi Valerie,you could use milk chocolate baking bar.
Excellent Thanks 🙂 im going to make this for Christmas eve ^_^
How long does this keep? I need to bake Monday for Thursday eve… Will it work?
Hi Gina Ann, when it’s cooled completely cover it well(not to dry out) and place back in the fridge.
Yes, but how far in advance can I make it?
You can keep it for a few days.
Hi, I’m in love with the comments on this recipe so I’m going to bake it tonight for tomorrow. Just a couple questions first. if I use salted butter, should I leave out the 1/4 tspn of salt? also, I don’t want to ruin this pie so what do I do about the possible bitterness? should I use semi sweet chocolate?
Hi Carrie, you should skip the salt if use salted butter,and about the possible bitterness,it rather depends on the manufacturer of chocolate, not all bitter-sweet chocolate the same, but if you want to be sure take sweet chocolate (especially if you’re not a fan of deep,dark chocolate flavor because a lot of cocoa also goes in this pie)
Happy baking 🙂
Can this be made sugar-free?
WOW! This is rich, smooth and utterly decadent, similar to the inside of a silky chocolate truffle, not the consistency of a brownie. I made this for Christmas and it got excellent reviews. I made a very small change to the recipe; I used 4 eggs and increased the sugar and butter slightly (maybe a tablespoon each). It was not difficult to make at all. YUM!
[…] >>> Recipe adapted from Omg Chocolate Desserts […]
Made this today for my husbands birthday. He loves dark chocolate and rich desserts. Followed the recipe exactly and it turned out amazing. Pairs great with vanilla ice cream.
So i use 2 whole eggs and 3 yolks??? So I’m gonna need 5 eggs to make this right???
Hi Crissy, yes you’ll need 5 eggs.
Will it be bad if I use the entire egg instead of just the yolk in the 2 yolks? thanks!
Hi Debora, I have not tried that way, but I guess it will not
[…] Ingredients: Chocolate Fudge Pie (adapted very slightly from here) […]
Can I use a graham cracker crust for this pie?
Hi Kay, I think you could do that.
for all the people who asked what is 1/2 & 1/2. It the little plastic tubs on the tables at restaurants to use in your coffee.
[…] Chocolate Fudge Pie […]
i just ate a slice of this and OH MY GOD GET IN MY GOSH DARN FACE IMMEDIATELY AND FOREVER that is all
I want to make this tonight I was wondering if I can do half bittersweet and Half semi sweet to avoid the bitter taste? Thank you.
This pie is excellent. I laughed when I saw in the comments that someone asked you, “What is half and half?” My son and I were on the internet looking for a chocolate pie recipe I could whip up for him out of the ingredients I had on hand… kept bypassing all the ones that called for cream… always have h-n-h in the fridge for our coffee! We LOVE bittersweet chocolate so I actually REDUCED the sugar to 1 cup. I used Ghiradelli Bittersweet Baking Chips (maybe it’s sweeter than some?) I am too lazy to make a pie crust from scratch, baked with a roll-out dough Pillsbury crust. Took it to a ladies’ dinner club gathering last night to rave reviews; gave your website full credit (tho I told them about my sweetener tweak).
Half and Half is in the refrigerated section between the milk and the coffee creamers. If you have heavy cream and whole milk mix a half a cup of each.
[…] Chocolate Fudge Pie from OMG Chocolate Desserts […]
This wasn’t bad but was pretty dry. the next time I make it, I think I’ll ad more half and half
im. making that
[…] Chocolate Fudge Pie … at Oh My Goodness […]
OMG it says serves 8-10 but all I need is a knife to slice it and a closet and I’m good to go
OMG! Such a good recipe. Made this last night for some friends that came over for dinner and it was a hit. Didn’t have half and half, but I did have heavy cream- did 2/3cup milk and 1/3cup heavy cream and it worked just fine. Had a bite of the leftovers after work and it’s even delicious cold. This is a keeper!
Thanks Jamie! Glad you liked it 🙂
I’ve made these a few times now and they always turn out perfect! I make them into small bite size tarts, perfect for a crowd to grab and go. I bake the small tarts at 350 for 22 minutes. Thanks for the recipe!!
Thanks Jessica. That sounds as a great idea. I might try that, too 🙂
Jessica, those would be great as treats for kids at school.
I think I will have to make this pie for Thanksgiving tomorrow.
Does this need to be refrigerated after it is made?
Hi Sandy, this should be served warm, but I like to eat it chilled from the fridge, too.
Made has directed, used a deep dish pie pan, then poured a chocolate gananche over it when cooled. Gave a even more fnished look and added to the chocolate overdose.
Thanks Scott!
[…] Chocolate Fudge Pie from OMG Chocolate Desserts […]
[…] If fudge and pie hooked up and had a baby, it would be this amazing chocolate fudge pie. […]
This is the best chocolate fudge pie ever—and it is easy! I have made it a dozen times and it is a hit every time. I use a premise frozen pie crust—be sure to use a deep dish pie crust.
Thanks Gail 🙂
I followed recipe exactly except I used. I’ll instead of half and half. It just seemed too gooey inside. I guess a toothpick shouldn’t come out clean? That’s for cakes not pies maybe? I even cooked it over an hour and increased the temp. What did I do wrong? Or was it right?
Turned out soo good! Used 4 whole eggs because I’m a rebel. Only had unsweetened chocolate so I had to do math, turns out the substitute for 1 oz bittersweet is 2/3 oz unsweetened + 2 tsp sugar.
I can feel the mood-lifting therapeutic medicinal chocolate-ness coursing through my brain when I eat it.
Thanks Andrea :-)!
[…] […]
[…] From: OMG Chocolate Desserts […]
I forgot to add that I use a ready made pie crust and just roll it into my pie plate. That’s the only thing “different” that I do. I also have vanilla ice cream waiting to top a warm piece later. Mmmmm!
[…] chocolate recipes, believe it or not, I shared only two chocolate pie recipes. So far, I made Chocolate Fudge Pie and French Silk […]
Can you make ahead and freeze it
Is it possible to pre everything today, and then bake it tomorrow?
Do we bake the crust before we bake then whole thing or do we just bake once with the filling?
looks and sounds so very good. making this today for our Thanksgiving dinner tomorrow. I’ll let you know how the like it.
#feelingconvident
What if I accidentally used an extra egg? I guess I’ll find out actually! It’s in the oven now! I thought I had read it correctly and made recipe to a “T”, however I read a review that said 5 eggs total, and I realized I used 6 total: 3 whole eggs and 3 egg yolks! Now I’m worried — but I’m a huge dark chocolate fan — AND I’m a baker!! I’ll write again!
Thank you !
An update to my original review (that I never saw published), so I don’t know if anyone will see this or not! Anyway, this pie is HEAVEN for true chocolate lovers! I had accidentally added an extra egg, so it was a tiny bit more “cakey” than fudgy! But still very decadent. I used 70% Lindell chocolate, special dark cocoa powder and it was very rich and delicious! It was not overly sweet! Helps chocolate cravings! A chocolate lovers dream!
Hello, I have made this pie a few times and always turns out perfect. I just wonder if I could freeze it if I need to make it well in advance.
Thanks